Home United States New Jersey Pizza restaurants Paone Pizzeria Restaurant Pizza restaurants

Paone Pizzeria Restaurant

4.5 126 reviews 555 Amboy Ave, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States

Discover this place

At Paone Pizzeria Restaurant, located on 555 Amboy Ave in Perth Amboy, NJ, pizza enthusiasts are in for a real treat. Many patrons rave about the generous portion sizes, particularly noting that the slices are not only large, but also commendably sturdy. One of the standout features is the pizzeria's ability to hold extra cheese without becoming soggy—a mark of skillful pizza craftsmanship.

Customers like Herman Gakarza have lauded its crisp yet thick crust, while Jeremy Urena highlights the garlic knots as a must-try, contributing to an overall stunning dining experience. The personal touch from the owner, who crafts pizzas right in front of customers, adds warmth to the occasion. Alexander Veras recalls being treated to a complimentary slice of Sicilian pizza, further emphasizing the welcoming atmosphere.

Ysmanol Batista speaks highly of Frank's dedication, stating he wouldn't consider anywhere else for pizza. The general consensus among visitors is clear: Paone’s pizzas are exceptional, combining quality ingredients and exceptional care, making it the best pizza restaurant in the area. If you seek a fulfilling pizza experience, Paone Pizzeria should be at the top of your list.

Photos

Paone Pizzeria Restaurant - Photo 1 Paone Pizzeria Restaurant - Photo 2 Paone Pizzeria Restaurant - Photo 3 Paone Pizzeria Restaurant - Photo 4 Paone Pizzeria Restaurant - Photo 5 Paone Pizzeria Restaurant - Photo 6

Amenities & More

Service options

  • Delivery
  • Takeout
  • Dine-in

Highlights

  • Fast service

Popular for

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Solo dining

Dining options

  • Lunch
  • Dinner
  • Table service

Amenities

  • Restroom

Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Cozy
  • Quiet
  • Trendy

Crowd

  • Groups
Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Paone Pizzeria Restaurant before visiting.

Reviews for Paone Pizzeria Restaurant

4.5
126 reviews
5
100%
4
8%
3
5%
2
3%
1
8%

Review highlights

Based on 126 reviews

Paone Pizzeria Restaurant in Perth Amboy is widely recognized for its generous portion sizes and consistently high-quality pizza that balances a crisp yet thick crust with ample, well-retained cheese. Reviewers frequently praise the freshness and flavor of the pies, highlighting both traditional and specialty options like Sicilian slices. The atmosphere is described as welcoming and casual, with the owner’s hands-on approach and friendly demeanor contributing to a personalized dining experience. Despite operating with limited staff, the restaurant maintains attention to detail, ensuring pizzas are not rushed and ingredients remain fresh. Additionally, complementary items such as garlic knots receive positive mention. Overall, Paone Pizzeria has earned a strong local reputation for delivering satisfying food and inviting service, making it a favored destination for pizza lovers in the Amboy area.

Herman Gakarza
Jun 23, 2025

Very big slices for 3. And very sturdy pizza. Holds extra cheese very well. Not soggy. Crisp yet thick. I recommend this place. It's definitely a contender for best Perth pizza.

Jeremy Urena
Jun 05, 2025

The pizza great, the garlic knots amazing, and the whole restaurant is just spectacular highly would recommend if craving pizza, best pizza I've eaten in years

Alexander Veras
May 29, 2025

Great Pizza! The owner gave me a free slice of Sicilian pizza which was amazing. He makes the pizza right in front of you and also makes you feel welcome.

Ysmanol Batista
Apr 24, 2025

I honestly love Frank's pizza. It was amazing It was my first time eating there today and I won't be going anywhere else for pizza in Amboy. His attitude was great and it's a cool place to eat with your friends. What surprised me is how good the pizza is even though he works by himself. I didn't expect much because one man and that many orders I would've expected a rushed pizza. But no it was perfect the crust, sauce, cheese, everything was perfect. Frank I love you my man keep doing what you're doing

Krisna Cruz
Apr 10, 2025

Best pizza in Amboy! Huge slices great taste done fresh.

LIVEONE THE REF
Mar 28, 2025

Just Moved to the Area and stopped in for a slice and ended up buying a small pepperoni pie well worth it. I've tried a few other pizza places in the area and they are terrible this place is old school great pizza for a fair price. Cash only

Jose Rivera
Mar 17, 2025

Amazing pizza the sauce is like no other highly recommended and affordable

Mari N
Mar 16, 2025

The man making the pizza is so nice & humble! The slices are delicious and have a great price. 10/10 would recommend!

Write a review

Share your experience with the community. Your honest feedback helps others find great places.

Quick info

Address
555 Amboy Ave, Perth Amboy, NJ 08861, United States
Price range
$1–10
Category
Pizza restaurants

Location

Own this business?

Claim this listing to update info, respond to reviews and reach more customers.

Claim listing

Discover more places like this

Browse thousands of bars, restaurants, cafés and more — wherever you go.

View Menu